Review form
1. This year's review form had four nonstandard fields intended to express the components of the merit judgment. Overall, how did the presence of these fields affect your reviewing experience?
 answered question43
 
skipped question
0
 Response
Percent
Response
Count
I found them very useful
11.6%5
I found them somewhat useful
30.2%13
DIdn't matter to me one way or another
32.6%14
I viewed them somewhat negatively
20.9%9
I viewed them very negatively
4.7%2
Further comment
view
14
2. If you had to design your own review form, which fields would you have?
 answered question41
 
skipped question
2
 Response
Percent
Response
Count
Overall merit
100.0%41
Expertise
73.2%30
Confidence in merit score
58.5%24
Quirkiness
4.9%2
Clarity
46.3%19
Conviction (convincingness of evidence)
41.5%17
Novelty
39.0%16
Importance
39.0%16
Other (list below)
4.9%2
Other (please specify)
view
6